Customer Rating:  
Summary: Some good points.
Comment: There are some relevant points in this book. The main point that I gathered from this reading is that our unconscious does some of the thinking for us, and decisions relating to this thinking are some of the best. However, if people were to think why they made these decisions, then they might not understand why they made the decision they made. Some of these decisions are based on intuition and result in good choices.
I believe this book to be the scraps left over from the Tipping Point. This book is written along the same lines, but some of this material seems to have less of a scientific appeal for me. I believe there are many relevant points in this book.
This is an OK read. I liked the Tipping Point and will see how I feel about Outliers.
Customer Rating:
Summary: More relevant than ever with recent election
Comment: This book is about impressions, biases, judgments, decision making and nonverbal communication. If you want to understand the Obama phenomenon and where its headed, read the chapter "The Warren Harding Error". Good book.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Is this a book?
Comment: I am not sure why this is a book. Anecdotes, anecdots, anecdotes.... Is there anything here that is actually researched and studied? A hundred stories does not a coherent theory make. This is typical Gladwell, big statements, good stories, poorly thought through thesis, bold assertions with no proof, keep cheerily going on, one book to the next. Good for killing time on a beach, but why would I pay for this advice?
Customer Rating:
Summary: Thought Provoking with Interesting Stories - bit confused
Comment: Based around the concept of thin-slicing, this book promotes the idea that your initial thoughts / gut feeling are often the right way to proceed (but not always). There are many case studies to hammer in the point and look at it from different perspectives. I feel the concept was a bit oversold, confused, and not pulled together nicely at the end.
In terms of the fundamental concept that we can learn to make better and faster decisions when we filter out excess data, I agree. This particularly holds if you are experienced in the field (i.e. with experience comes intuition).
As for the "Compelling", "Astonishing" and "Brilliant" words being used to describe this book, I think that maybe "Thought Provoking with Interesting Stories" might be a better way to describe it.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Insights into race
Comment: The people who reviewed this book poorly may not have to deal with race issues. Even though I'm Navajo, Gladwell makes some astute humanitarian and race observations that have whirled around in my head for years. He makes affirmations about my theories of race and our denials of our repressed feelings. I did the test of associating good with African American image, and I even struggled with it. I liked Gladwell's honest approach.
He also exhibits a great writing style. Though I read Blink several weeks ago, I'm still talking about it. My gushing comments inspired friends to buy the book for friends, spouses, and even themselves. Get this, I broked away from my gym workout to discuss Blink with a friend. Since I take my gym seriously, this is an all time new one. I've lent my copy out, and when I get it back, I want to explore the researchers of classifying facial expressions. In the meantime, I'll get Tipping Point.
Thank you, Malcolm, for your work. It's great to find an author who sees the world as I do. We must find avenues to get along without the superficial talk and denial. I'll write again if I mimic my reaction at the gym after reading Tipping Point.
|
